Skip to main content

Study Shows Deceptive Ads Directed to Children; Advocacy Groups Push for FTC Sanctions; CARU Remains Active in the Space


A number of child advocacy groups are worried after the release of a research study suggesting that popular apps for children in the iOS and Android systems feature advertisements that prompt and encourage young children to ma
ke in-app purchases, collect their personal data, and distract them from the in-game experience.

The study, titled “Advertising in Young Children’s Apps: A Content Analysis”, was written by a group of researchers headed by Jenny Radesky, who is a behavioral pediatrician at the University of Michigan Medical School. The research looked at 135 children’s apps including those in the “Ages 5 and Under” category, both paid and free and both from the Android and iOS app. The study found that in the sample, 88% of paid children’s apps and all of free children’s apps had advertisements, which varied in form and effect towards children.

The study noted various ways that advertisements were deceptive. The study noted that some advertisements were designed to look like a part of the game but were actually “camouflaged ads”. Other advertisements entice children to make in-app purchases, some even showing distressing images like children crying so that young players will make purchases. Other advertisements had mini-games that children could not play unless they watch an ad, or get bonuses when they watch an ad. These ads, as Radesky pointed out, can take advantage of children who do not yet have the “critical thinking skills to understand the ‘persuasive intent’ of an advertisement”, so they can get profit via clicks.

Josh Golin, the executive director of the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood, mentioned in a BuzzFeed News report, hopes that “the FTC will fine the app developers and fine them enough that it sends a clear message to the preschool app industry.”

Prohibitions on product placement and instances where a character encourages children to make purchases only apply to television at present, and do not apply to the internet. However, CARU has had several cases that cover the exact issues of concern in the University of Michigan study.

Specifically, in CARU’s Barbie Sparkle Blast case (#6112), CARU determined that the app did not clearly and conspicuously disclose where there was advertising. In between levels during gameplay, video advertisements that popped up had to be watched in their entirety before players were able to move on. Users could also choose to watch videos to earn free virtual currency to purchase virtual items. Neither of these advertisements disclosed that they were advertising. Therefore, CARU recommended that the operator include adequate disclosures on all ads, which the operator immediately implemented. Similarly, CARU has held that online games or activities that feature products must use prominent disclosures to make the advertising nature of the game known (Dum-Dums #5258, Kellogg’s Froot Loops #5493).

The study also referenced an app that showed kids crying if they did not click on an in-app purchase. CARU had a similar case that covered this precise issue. In CARU’s Mall Girl App inquiry (#5594), there was a message to kids that stated “Your pet is going to be taken away by the SPCA for animal neglect! Pay a fine to keep your pet.” If the player did not have enough virtual currency, a player could purchase virtual cash with real money. Indeed, because of the game structure, users effectively had no choice but to make a purchase because it was nearly impossible to have enough currency otherwise. CARU determined that the app created a sense of urgency to save the player’s virtual pet and recommended that the operator discontinue this message, which it did. CARU’s FooPets.com case (#5314) covered similarly misleading advertising practices and sales pressure issues. In this case, the advertiser did not disclose that users had to become paid members to access certain gameplay features. The app also used extremely persuasive language to try and convince kids to join the service.

The report also mentioned banner ads that were inappropriate for kids, the researchers said. CARU’s guidelines specifically prohibit this practice, disallowing advertisers from portraying inappropriate behavior/content or from knowingly linking to pages that portray such behavior or material (CARU Guidelines Section (i)(2)(b).

Finally, it is worth mentioning that CARU actually had a case with one of the app developers investigated in the study, Outfit7, the creator of the Talking Tom Cat apps. CARU cited the company with similar violations that were mentioned in the study, namely that the app did not adequately disclose that advertising was in fact advertising. When such an instance of noncompliance occurs, CARU has the power to open a compliance investigation and request that the advertiser report on the advertising at issue and explain its practices. If the advertiser does not respond or show that it has made a reasonable attempt to comply, CARU shall refer the file to the appropriate government agency.

CARU does valuable work and is doing its best to help address these issues. And we can always use your help! CARU accepts consumer complaints. Consumers are on the front lines and CARU welcomes anonymous submission of any issues consumers encounter. We check these regularly and follow through on all of these.

If you have any questions about advertising practices, please don't hesitate to reach out to CARU at info@caru.bbb.org.

Popular posts from this blog

5 Key Takeaways from IAPP's #GPS18 Conference

The Children's Advertising Review Unit (CARU) attended the International Association of Data and Privacy Professionals' (IAPP) Data Privacy Summit in Washington D.C. last week. It was a great opportunity to spend time with important folks in the privacy industry. Panelists ranged from regulators to specialists on topics like GDPR, ethical data use and new technologies like facial recognition. It was a great event.



Here are CARU's key takeaways from IAPP's Data Privacy Summit.

1. GDPR was the Star
GDPR was paid a lot of attention--and with good reason. One panel answered a very serious question--will there be a grace period? According to Andrea Jelinek (current head of the Article 29 Working Party), there will be a two-day grace period because GDPR goes into effect on a Friday. So essentially, take the weekend, but they'll see you bright and early Monday morning. Other questions linger about whether GDPR principles become the norm because easier than parsing o…

Safety Tips for Parents Buying Smart and Connected Toys This Holiday Season

Teddy bears once filled with stuffing are now hard-wired with smart technology. Internet-connected toys can be fun but they can also put your family at risk if proper care is not taken when buying and using these devices.

Now, more than ever before, The Children’s Advertising Review Unit (CARU) encounters toys that may collect personal information (e.g. name, email address) from children. Unfortunately, this may be done without parents knowing it’s happening. Much like many offline experiences where parent’s permission is required before collecting or using your child’s information, the online world is the same: parental permission is required! These connected toys aren’t inherently bad; in fact, they can be highly educational and fun as long as parents are well-informed and choose wisely. But if you choose the wrong toy, there can be consequences (check out our issues we had with a recent smart toy here) Santa checks his list twice and responsible parents should too-- you may be surpr…

CARU to Host its First Conference in San Francisco on May 2, 2018

Join The Children's Advertising Review Unit (CARU) on May 2, 2018 at its first-ever San Francisco Conference. CARU typically hosts an annual conference on the East Coast but is looking forward to connecting the major players in the children’s advertising industry with the tech industries to examine the complex issues that arise when marketing to children. The conference will examine legal trends and review the latest developments in advertising and online privacy. Our dynamic panels will offer unique perspectives on privacy issues worldwide, adapting to new technology, social media, working with influencers and even why corporate social responsibility is good for your bottom line.

This can’t-miss conference will examine the latest innovations and trends, and explore strategies and solutions to drive your business forward whilst still complying with CARU’s guidelines and relevant laws. Leave with inspiration and practical advice about connected toys, social media marketing and com…